Skip to content 
The tragedy unfolded at a family member’s home in Shelby County. Anna Southard had been planning to take her daughter to an appointment but was convinced by family to leave Ember behind for what they promised would be a twenty-minute window. It was a decision that would haunt Anna for the rest of her life. She hadn’t even reached the doctor’s office when the phone rang, signaling that her world was about to collapse. She rushed back to the scene, arriving just moments after the ambulance, only to be met with a sight that no parent should ever have to witness.
Her daughter appeared lifeless. The medical emergency that followed was a desperate, agonizing blur. Anna found herself on her knees in the driveway, the physical pain of the impact mirroring the catastrophic trauma of hearing the words “dog attack.” The culprit was an 11-year-old American Bully—a dog that the family had known for years and that had never previously shown a single sign of aggression. It was a family pet, an animal they felt safe with, yet it was the very instrument of Ember’s untimely death.
Despite the heroic efforts of over a dozen doctors at the Children’s Hospital, the prognosis was grim from the start. Anna stayed by her side, pleading, hoping, and begging for a miracle that would not come. At 1:10 p.m., the medical team confirmed that Ember had passed away. In the aftermath, as Anna grappled with the soul-crushing task of cleaning the blood from her daughter’s body and wrapping her in warm blankets to ensure she wouldn’t be cold, she began to process the reality of the negligence that had cost her “perfect noodle” her life.